The Alcuin Society

Alcuin Society Book Design Awards22nd Annual Awards for
Excellence in Book Design
in Canada

2003

Children | Limited Editions | Pictorial | Poetry
Prose Fiction | Prose Non-Fiction
Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated | Reference

This Year's Judges:

Susan Colberg is Assistant Professor of Visual Communication Design at the University of Alberta, in Edmonton, where she teaches beginning and advanced typography, information design and the practice of graphic design to graduate and undergraduate students. Her practice focuses on book and publication design and her clients include a variety of institutional and scholarly publishing houses in Canada and the U.S. She has won numerous national and international awards for her work and is Past-president of the of Alberta Chapter of the Society of Graphic Designers of Canada.

Randall Speller is a librarian in the Art Gallery of Ontario in Toronto, where he has worked since 1980. He has combined a career in art librarianship with an interest in Canadian literature and book collecting to influence his research into the history of Canadian book illustration and design, especially in the years following World War II. Randall is a contributing editor to the DA: a Journal of the Printing Arts, where he has written several articles on book illustration and design.

Matthew Warburton, FGDC, a print-based designer with over 20 years experience, began his career in 1983 as a headline typographer at Typsettra in Toronto, followed by 4 years at Gottschalk + Ash. He moved to Vancouver in 1989, working with Herrainco Design Associates before founding Emdoubleyu Design in 1997. Matthew has been actively involved with the Society of Graphic Designers of Canada since 1990 (currently as GDC National President), and was President of the BC Chapter from 1997 to 2000. His work with the GDC has enabled him to promote the economic benefits of a strong community of graphic designers. In 2003, he became the 53rd Fellow of the GDC, a recognition given to those who have made a major contribution to the graphic design profession in Canada.

Children's Books^ back to top

1st Prize

Title

Le Grand Rêve De Passepoil

Designer

Primeau & Barey

Author

Elaine Arsenault

Publisher

Dominique et Compagnie

Illustrator

Fanny

Printer

Imprimeries Transcontinental Inc.

Comments

The charming and delightful illustrations in Le Grand Rêve De Passepoil, combined with its spirited typography, delighted all the judges. What is so evident in a production such as this is how closely the designer and illustrator have worked together. Illustration and text are wonderfully well-integrated, and all the book's various parts work in harmony. The result is a warm and humorous book.

2nd Prize

Title

Sink or Swim

Designer

Tammy Desnoyers

Author

Valerie Coulman

Publisher

Lobster Press

Illustrator

Rogé Gerard

Printer

Sheck Wah Tong (Hong Kong)

Comments

This warm, lively, and engaging book was a close runner up. The pictures on their own do a wonderful job of telling the story, nonetheless the text is carefully integrated into the images and both work extremely well together. We love this wonderfully fun book.

3rd Prize

Title

Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

Designer

Judith Steedman (Steedman Design)

Author

Lewis Carroll

Publisher

Simply Read Books

Illustrator

Iassen Ghiuselev

Printer

Graphiche AZ

Comments

The judges could not agree on where to place this book. Those who love its elegant traditional approach thought it deserved first place. Awarding it third place was a reluctant compromise. Nonetheless Alice's Adventures has many outstanding features to recommend it. The cover is outstanding, arguably the best in the show. The illustrations and calligraphy are as elegant as the typography, and the designer has made excellent use of the white space and the limited colour ranges. This book is a timeless design classic in the making.

Hon. Mention

Title

Always Run Up the Stairs

Designer

Robin Mitchell

Author

Sean Moore

Publisher

Simply Read Books

Illustrator

Sean Moore

Printer

Grafiche AZ

Comments

The quirky offbeat style of Always Run Up the Stairs delighted the judges. The typography is fun and is well integrated with the delightful illustrations. The illustrator makes good use of the limited range of colours.

Hon. Mention

Title

Emilie Pleine de Jouets

Designer

Primeau & Barey

Author

Gilles Tibo

Publisher

Dominique et compagnie

Illustrator

Marie Lafrance

Printer

Everbest Printing Co. Ltd

Hon. Mention

Title

Sunny

Designer

Robin Mitchell & Judith Steedman

Author

Robin Mitchell & Judith Steedman

Publisher

Simply Read Books

Illustrator

Robin Mitchell & Judith Steedman

Printer

Grafiche AZ

Comments

Strong entries by Robin Mitchell and Judith Steedman (Sunny [Simply Read Books]) and Gilles Tibo (Emilie pleine de jouets [Dominique et compagnie]) also delighted all the judges. There were so many wonderful books and too few prizes.

Limited Editions

1st Prize

Title

The Gryphons of Paris : A Reliquary of Photographs and Vignettes

Designer

Michael Torosian

Author

Ronald Hurwitz

Publisher

Voirin Editions

Photographer

Ronald Hurwitz

Printer

Michael Torosian - Lumiere Press

Comments

The Gryphons of Paris is, in this category, by far the superior production. From its elegant case binding and spine treatment and its beautifully toned paper, right down to its flawless letterpress and its exquisitely printed duotone stochastic lithographs, there is hardly a note out of place. Our only quibble, is with the head and tail bands. They are so white. A more subtle colour would be so much more elegant.

2nd Prize

Title

The Land Beyond

Designer

Jason Dewinetz

Author

Matt Rader

Publisher

Greenboathouse Books

Photographer

Jason Dewinetz

Printer

Greenboathouse Books

Comments

The judges were intrigued by the simple but effective cover on The Land Beyond. The colour reproduction on the cover is of surprisingly good quality and it is a perfect match for the cover stock. The simple binding suits the subject to perfection, but it is the way the title bleeds off the page (a feature that is echoed on the half-title and title page) that we found so mysterious and intriguing. The effect is subtle but evocative. The letterpress and typography are themselves clean and elegant, and the format suits the content.

3rd Prize

Title

The Dot and the Line

Designer

Mimi Lin

Author

Norton Juster

Publisher

Mimi Lin / Centennial Bookbinding

Illustrator

Mimi Lin

Printer

Mimi Lin

Comments

We were all delighted by the playful typographic images used to illustrate the hard-cover and the text. Enclosed in a box covered with eye-catching black and white polka-dot fabric (the same fabric was used on the endpapers [should it have been better quality cloth?]), this playful production features lots of nice design touches. There is much to amuse and entertain. Unfortunately the colour of the cloth used on the spine does not relate well to the decorative cloth case. Another choice might have been more effective.

Hon. Mention

Title

Mountain Journal

Designer

Arnold Shives, Martin Hunt, Barbarian Press

Author

Arnold Shives

Publisher

Prospect Press

Illustrator

Arnold Shives

Printer

Barbarian Press, Blackstone Press

Comments

The outstanding feature of this production is the beautiful letterpress printing. It really is exceptional, as are the limited edition colour prints. Unfortunately the title page and cover are not composed with the same care. Neither the cover illustration nor the typography are handled as well as the text.

Pictorial^ back to top

1st Prize

Title

The Group of Seven and Tom Thomson

Designer

Linda Gustafson

Author

David P. Silcox

Publisher

Firefly Books Ltd

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

This attractive book won for its elegant and restrained handling of every feature. The pacing of the images and text as well as the harmony of images on facing pages are both superb. The designer has been very sensitive to subtle details, such as the paper tone (champagne for text and white for images), the fine printing, and the lovely sense of balance on the pages. Even the case design is excellent with its foil stamping and paper covering. The case is, in our estimation, better than the dust jacket. Be sure to remove the dust jacket and appreciate what has been done here.

2nd Prize

Title

Le Design au Québec

Designer

Josée Amyotte

Author

Marc H. Choko, Paul Bourassa, & Gérald Baril

Publisher

Les éditions de l'homme

Illustrator

Mélanie Sabourin & Jean Angrignon-Sirois

Printer

Imprimerie Interglobe (Transcontinental)

Comments

As one would expect, Le Design au Quebec is a superbly-designed book. The production values are all exquisite. Its presentation of image and text, its balance and its pacing are all meticulously-considered. What delighted the judges was the sensitive grouping of images, a feature that helps show every one of these photographs in their historical context, and to their best advantage. The use of colour fields to frame and highlight the grouped images is also highly effective. We feel the typography is not as good as it could have been. It feels a little heavy handed, especially when everything else has been done so beautifully.

3rd Prize

Title

Alex Colville : Return

Designer

George Vaitkunas

Author

Tom Smart

Publisher

Douglas & McIntyre

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

It was the perfectly-balanced spreads and sensitive image and text relationships that won this book an award. The design layout is intimately connected to the subject matter; the asymmetrical page composition show the same edge found in Colville's work. The typography is clean and perfectly suits the project. This book is a beautiful piece of design, but along its well-chosen path, no risks were taken.

Hon. Mention

Title

Les Documents de la Chambre des Cultures

Designer

Mike Teixeira

Author

Annie Thibault & Anne Bénichou

Publisher

Centre d'artistes anexe07

Printer

St Joseph Corporation

Comments

This design combines an interesting mixture of images with adventuresome typography that still manages to remain understated and balanced. We love the use of different paper stocks and colours to define areas of the book (such as the blue paper for the index). There are some problems, we feel, with letter spacing that, had they been resolved, would result in a much better piece.

Hon. Mention

Title

Sylvia Safdie : The Inventories of Invention = Les Inventaires de L'Imaginaire

Designer

Fugazi

Author

Sylvia Safdie; text, Irena Zantovskà-Murray, Stuart Reid

Publisher

Leonard & Bina Art Gallery

Printer

Integria

Comments

With its carefully-considered sequencing of differently-scaled images, its subtle typography and good use of white space, Sylvie Safdie is a design of understated elegance. It is a lovely book.

Poetry^ back to top

1st Prize

Title

Ursa Major : A Polyphonic Masque for Speakers & Dancers

Designer

Andrew Steeves with Robert Bringhurst

Author

Robert Bringhurst

Illustrator

Wesley Bates (wood engraving)

Printer

Gaspereau Press

Comments

This is an elegant production from top to bottom. All of its elements are well-considered, from the exquisite typography by Canada's master typographer right down to the lovely tone of paper. We were fascinated by the wonderful integration of the three languages on the page using type and different coloured inks. Truly an amazing book.

2nd Prize

Title

Small Arguments

Designer

Zab Design & Typography

Author

Souvankham Thammavongsa

Publisher

Pedlar Press

Printer

Coach House Printing

Comments

Small was the watchword for this designer; the small format and small-scale type are more than appropriate for the theme and content. The playful typography is wonderfully controlled by the carefully determined line breaks, the spacing, and the use of white space on the page. Enclosing it all is a simple, appealing cover.

3rd Prize

Title

An Ark of Koans

Designer

Alan Brownoff

Author

E.D. Blodgett

Publisher

The University of Alberta Press

Illustrator

Jacques Brault

Printer

Kromar Printing

Comments

Blodgett's book is another small, intimate production, enhanced with delicate and sensitive illustrations that are beautifully integrated with the typography both on the cover and in the interior.

Hon. Mention

Title

Persuasion for a Mathematician

Designer

Zab Design & Typography

Author

Joanne Page

Publisher

Pedlar Press

Illustrator

Ryan Price (cover)

Printer

Kromar Printing

Comments

The overall design is excellent, and all the elements work well together. We all thought the cover was intriguing. A delightful and fun book.

Prose Fiction^ back to top

1st Prize

Title

Lightning

Designer

Peter Cocking

Author

Fred Stenson

Publisher

Douglas & McIntyre

Illustrator

Bettman/Corbis/Magma (jacket)

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

Everything comes together in Lightning, from its cover right down to the smallest interior detail. The strong dust jacket is evocative and attractive, the case cover and endpapers harmonize beautifully, and we all admired the well-handled introductory and title pages. The interior proportions are good, and the text block is nicely balanced on the page. The paper has a lovely warm tone, and contrasts nicely with the well-chosen type. The dropped capitals are very well done.

2nd Prize

Title

Mme. Proust and the Kosher Kitchen

Designer

CS Richardson

Author

Kate Taylor

Publisher

Doubleday Canada

Illustrator

Kara Kosaka (jacket)

Comments

We love the cover of this book, as well as many of its fine interior details. The text proportions are excellent, the paper has a warm tone, and the typography has a lovely open and subtle quality. As part of the story is told via a series of letters, the designer has done a wonderful job using different type in a subtle and sophisticated way to differentiate the correspondence from the text. We feel the half-title and title pages are weaker than the first prize entry. We also feel that the dropped capitals on the otherwise well-handled chapter entries are too far away from the words that follow. Nonetheless this is a fine production, and a pleasant book to read.

3rd Prize

Title

Vaudeville!

Designer

Bill Douglas at The Bang (cover)

Author

Gaétan Soucy

Publisher

House of Anansi Press

Photographer

The Bang Archives, Photonica

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

Again, another strong and attractive cover caught our attention; the tight integration of type and illustration is handled very well by the designer. Unfortunately, the typeface on the cover is not used in any of the interior pages, and the judges feel a wonderful opportunity has been lost. The typography, nevertheless, is attractive and clearly set; it's subtle and doesn't try too hard, a feature that, in the end, impressed all of us. The introductory pages, especially the half-title and title pages, are also nicely done. Some details don't work well. The section heads don't relate well to the rest of the text, and the chapter numbers are centred while the page numbers aren't. We feel this is a bit awkward.

Hon. Mention

Title

Cat's Crossing

Designer

CS Richardson

Author

Bill Cameron

Publisher

Random House Canada

Printer

R.R. Donnelley

Comments

We love the running cat motif. If you flip the pages, the cat appears to run across the bottom of the page. This type of graphic element doesn't always work but here it manages to be subtle, witty and charming all at the same time.

Hon. Mention

Title

Stevenson Under the Palm Trees

Designer

Gordon Robertson (text design)

Author

Alberto Manguel

Publisher

Thomas Allen Publishers

Photographer

Minori Kawana/Photonica

Illustrator

Robert Louis Stevenson

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

The text interior of this book is excellent, its strong well-balanced design and the journal-like format are comfortable, easy to hold, and give an intimate feel to the book. There is also a very nice use of illustration. The dust jacket, on the other hand, is too stiff and doesn't feel like it belongs on such a small book. None of the various cover elements (the illustration, the typography and the colouring) work harmoniously together.

Hon. Mention

Title

Would You Hide Me?

Designer

Andrew Steeves at Gaspereau Press

Author

J.J. Steinfeld

Publisher

Gaspereau Press

Printer

Gaspereau Press

Comments

The cover is very attractive with strong typographic images on the dust jacket, the title page, and on the paper casing. The lead-in pages are excellent, but the text typography is too "loud", far too heavy, and would benefit from more generous leading.

Prose Non-Fiction^ back to top

1st Prize

Title

Wisdom & Metaphor

Designer

Andrew Steeves at Gaspereau Press

Author

Jan Zwicky

Publisher

Gaspereau Press

Printer

Gaspereau Press

Comments

This book is an aesthetic delight, and proves to be a wonderfully designed package. In every decision made, the designer was sensitive to the subject of the book. We love the large format, the elegant white-on-white dust jacket, and the tone-on-tone off-white paper case. The choice of paper for the text was remarkable; the bright white paper gives the type a lovely crisp appearance. Great use is made of the white space on the page. The diagrams are well-integrated, and the half-title and title pages are balanced and beautiful. The type is spare, but more open leading would make it absolutely perfect in the eyes of some judges. The vertical linear elements, too, are a bit heavy-handed, especially when the rest of the design work is so delicate. This is a small quibble about an otherwise impressive production.

2nd Prize

Title

Village of the Small Houses : A Memoir of Sorts

Designer

Jessica Sullivan

Author

Ian Ferguson

Publisher

Douglas & McIntyre

Photographer

Ian Ferguson

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

Village of Small Houses was a very strong contender for first place. Almost all the design elements are well-composed. The cover is excellent and the cover image could not be more appropriate. The introduction is nicely done, and the text pages are all well-proportioned. The type size, colouring, and leading are all excellent, and there are some very interesting typographic contrasts. Some of us feel the chapter headings are slightly heavy, and the first letter too stylized and large. Otherwise this is a remarkably well-designed book.

3rd Prize

Title

Open House : Canada and the Magic of Curling

Designer

CS Richardson

Author

Scott Russell

Publisher

Doubleday Canada

Photographer

National Archives of Canada (jacket); Corbis/Magma

Comments

We all feel Open House is engaging, accessible, and very well-designed. The cover is appropriate to the subject. We love the playful introductory pages with the curling rock shown moving across the pages. This could easily have descended into kitsch, but it adds warmth and humour to the page. The running chapter and title headings are beautifully done, in reduced tones, and the typography is sound. We feel the integration of the photographs is occasionally awkward and the reproduction quality of the photographs is not what it should be.

Hon. Mention

Title

Dad Alone : How to Rebuild Your Life and Remain an Involved Father After Divorce

Designer

David Drummond (Salamander Hill Design)(cover); Simon Dardick (text)

Author

Phil Clavel

Publisher

Véhicule Press

Printer

AGMV-Marquis Inc.

Comments

The appealing cover of Dad Alone was created by a designer who understands the relationship between subject, content, typography and image. All work nicely together. We love its no-nonsense format, so appropriate for the time-short, harried father. The interior pages are well handled and the information well-structured.

Hon. Mention

Title

Scurvy : How a Surgeon, a Mariner, and a Gentleman Solved the Greatest Medical Mystery of the Age of Sail

Designer

Gordon Robertson

Author

Stephen R. Bown

Publisher

Thomas Allen Publishers

Illustrator

Alfredo Carmelo

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

Overall Scurvy shows great sensitivity to its contents and ideas. The cover is excellent, but some of us feel the typography is heavy-handed on the text pages and chapter headings. Overall, the book demonstrates remarkable design consistency.

Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated^ back to top

1st Prize (tie)

Title

Temptress : From the Original Bad Girls to Women on Top

Designer

Peter Cocking & Val Speidel

Author

Jane Billinghurst

Publisher

Douglas & McIntyre

Illustrator

John Collier

Printer

C.S. Graphics Pte. Led

Comments

This richly-illustrated and lavish production could easily have gone over the top, but the designer has embraced the inherent risks and has managed to hold everything together in a remarkable design. The pacing and balance in this book are superb; the relationship between image and text excellent, and the text type is nicely set and has an appropriate tone. The chapter headings are excellent. The designer must receive full credit here.

1st Prize (tie)

Title

Traces of India = Empreintes de L'inde [English & French editions]

Designer

Zab Design & Typography

Author

Maria Antonella Pelizzari, editor

Publisher

Canadian Centre for Architecture

Printer

Litho Acme

Comments

The design works brilliantly in both language editions of Traces of India, where text block and line lengths can be so different in French and English. There is a nice, clean structure in both of these books. The balance of text and image is superb, and the changes of scale add visual interest. The beauty of these images is allowed to take centre stage. The remarkable pacing and layout draw the reader along and seldom falter. The choice of typography is excellent, and the type hierarchies are subtle yet functional. The divider pages make good use of second colours, but more care should have been taken with the colour and/or placement of the type on these colour fields; in some cases the text is difficult to read. Nonetheless this an outstanding production.

2nd Prize

Title

Godless at the Workbench = Sans-Dieu à L'Atelier : Soviet Illustrated Humoristic Antireligious Propaganda

Designer

Zab Design & Typography

Author

Annie Gérin

Publisher

Dunlop Art Gallery

Photographer

Don Hall & David King

Printer

Kromar

Comments

The cover to Godless at the Workbench is indeed intriguing. Its appeal is immediate, but there are other parts of this book worth noting. The endpapers are beautiful. Using the subject to determine the design style of the book was a logical choice for this project. The typography, in a Russian constructivist/early 20th century style, is very well-done, as are the captions for the illustrations, and more remarkably, the footnotes.

3rd Prize

Title

Remembering Phil Esposito : A Celebration

Designer

Bill Douglas

Author

Craig MacInnis, editor

Publisher

Raincoast Books

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

This book is a great compilation of memorable images, text, quotes and stories. Remembering Phil Esposito is well presented in a highly suitable format that is appropriate for its audience. The strong dust jacket works well with the case, which is simply designed in appropriate colours. The reproductions are very good considering they have been printed on uncoated paper, which itself has a lovely tone. The typography we feel is a bit heavy-handed in some areas and this lost the book a higher place. The running heads also are too tightly spaced in our estimation. They have a "squeezed" look.

Hon. Mention

Title

The Lands Within Me : Expressions by Canadian Artists of Arab Origin

Designer

Bleu Outremer Communication/Design

Author

Aïda Kaouk & Dominique Bourque, editors

Publisher

Canadian Museum of Civilization

Printer

K2 Impressions

Comments

This exhibition catalogue is presented in a manner that is playful yet still maintains a contemporary feel in its design. The handling of the photographic illustrations and pictorial matter is lively and varied, and there is good use of colour. The introductory sections on each artist are also very well done. Some of the judges feel the columns are a bit tight, and that "Democratica" typeface is an odd choice for this project.

Reference^ back to top

1st Prize

Title

Le Nouveau Dictionnaire Multilingue : Français, Anglais, Espagnol, Allemand, Italien

Designer

Anne Tremblay

Author

Jean-Claude Corbeil & Ariane Archambault

Publisher

Les éditions Québec Amérique, Inc.

Illustrator

QA Digital

Printer

Neografia

Comments

This impressively comprehensive, multilingual dictionary of visual images is not only a pleasure to look at, but is clearly layed-out and easy to navigate. Such a clean and simple design could not have been an easy task considering the dictionary's size and weight. Nonetheless, the sections are not only colour-coded, but there is also a multilingual index in French, English, Spanish, German, and Italian. Here we have a complex project that has been transformed into an impressive, useable and pleasant reference book by a talented designer.

2nd Prize

Title

Historical Atlas of the Arctic

Designer

Derek Hayes (interior) and George Vaitkunas (jacket)

Author

Derek Hayes

Publisher

Douglas & McIntyre

Printer

C & C Offset (Hong Kong)

Comments

Douglas & McIntyre's Historical Atlas series continues to be a hallmark of design excellence. This new Atlas of the Arctic is a very beautiful book, and contains all the features one expects from the publisher. The contents are well layed-out, and the integration of text and images is excellent. The map reproductions are superb, the pacing is wonderful, and the exquisite typography is clear, clean and restrained. A well-designed and beautiful book.

3rd Prize

Title

What Directors Need to Know : Corporate Governance 2003

Designer

Bruce Mau Design Inc: Bruce Mau with Barr Gilmore, Judith McKay and Cathy Johasson

Author

Carol Hansell

Publisher

Carswell

Photographer

Lorne Bridgman

Printer

Transcontinental

Comments

If a reference book is not designed well, it does not work well. Corporate Governance structures its complex subject matter in an accessible and attractive package. Attention has been paid to all the details that count. The hierarchy of information, as defined by the typography, is cleanly and clearly layed-out on the page. The detailed diagrams and charts are well-integrated with the text. The design makes clear the function.

Hon. Mention

Title

Lumiére Light : Recipes from the Tasting Bar

Designer

Peter Cocking with Jessica Sullivan

Author

Rob Feenie & Marnie Coldham

Publisher

Douglas & McIntyre

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

Of all the cookbooks we saw Lumiere Light is the one we liked the best. Everything we wanted to see was here; the book is aesthetically appealing, well-designed, and functional. The hierarchy of food preparation tasks is outlined clearly and logically, and the format is practical enough for use in the kitchen.

Hon. Mention

Title

The Wood Design Awards 2003 : A North American Program of Architectural Excellence

Designer

Marie-Noëlle Massé

Author

Don Griffith, editor

Publisher

Tuns Press and Janam Publications

Printer

Friesens Book Division

Comments

Along with its clean layout and its clear black and white photographs, the sequencing and pacing of this catalogue are among its finest features. In addition, the integration of illustrated matter (architectural plans) with photographs is very well done. Unfortunately, the wonderfully rich colour cover promises more than it can deliver. It is perhaps, misleading as far as the representation of the content of the book is concerned, in that there are no colour illustrations within the text. We said the same thing about the 2002 edition.

^ back to top