The Alcuin Society

Alcuin Society Book Design Awards24th Annual Awards for
Excellence in Book Design
in Canada

for books published in
2005

Français | This Year's Judges

 

Poetry

The judges are well aware that most of the best-designed poetry books published in Canada during the year were not submitted to the competition. Those that were submitted vary considerably in typographic quality; it is, in the best books, higher than in the non-fiction books that were submitted, but many of the books that we see here are typographically undistinguished. There are many examples of good type poorly used, and some examples of poor type partially redeemed through careful attention to detail. We did not find a book to which we wanted to give a first prize.

Poetry 2nd Prize back to general winners

Title

Signs of the Times

Designer

David Bircham

Author

Bud Osborn

Publisher

Anvil Press & Signs of the Times

Illustrator

Richard Tetrault

Printer

Hignell Printing (Winnipeg)

Trim Size

24 × 19cm

Signs of the Times

Comments

Signs of the Times is the most graphically ambitious of the books submitted. The illustrations are a very important part of the overall effect. The type is very carefully set. It is curious that the typographer chose to use eighteenth-century decorative ligatures, "st" and "ct" ligatures, for example, and yet could not be bothered to find a decent set of text figures. While the type and the images seem to us well chosen, they do not always seem to be balanced against one another or integrated with one another. The elements sometimes seem out of scale with the page and with the book.

Poetry Hon. Mention back to general winners

Title

Ligatures

Designer

Blaine Kyllo (Solocorps)

Author

Donato Mancini

Publisher

New Star Books

Printer

Gauvin Press

Trim Size

14 × 22cm

Ligatures

Comments

The cover is disappointing. There is, however, some sophisticated and intriguing typographic play inside the book. Whether or not there is any real relationship between this typographic play and the content of the poetry is not quite clear. The illustrations seem to be graphic interruptions more than they are graphic amplifications or additions to the text.

Poetry Hon. Mention back to general winners

Title

The Sleep of Four Cities

Designer

Rayola Graphic Design (cover); HeimatHouse (interior)

Author

Jen Currin

Publisher

Anvil Press

Illustrator

Houghton Boston Printers (Saskatoon)

Trim Size

14 × 19cm

The Sleep of Four Cities

Comments

This has one of the best covers we saw in this category. The letterspacing of the capitals is well done. The typography, otherwise, is undistinguished. The book was set without ligatures, which it does need. There is, however, adequate spacing between and around the lines, which helps considerably to make a book inviting to read. More attention to typographic detail would have been very welcome.

Poetry Hon. Mention back to general winners

Title

Stormy Weather : Foursomes

Designer

Zab Design & Typography

Author

Stan Dragland

Publisher

Pedlar Press

Illustrator

Ryan Price (cover art)

Printer

Kromar Printing Ltd

Trim Size

18 × 11cm

Emily : Opposites Attract

Comments

A pleasant little book, handsomely diminutive in size. The typographer has gone to the trouble of getting real musical symbols where they were required. The justification, however, is poor. This is a difficulty because this book of poetry is written almost entirely in prose.

^ back to top