The Alcuin Society

Alcuin Society Book Design Awards24th Annual Awards for
Excellence in Book Design
in Canada

2005

Français | This Year's Judges

1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005

Prose Non-Fiction

There were no outstanding entries in this category. A number of the books submitted have nice covers but very disappointing interiors. The best books are no more than competent: adequate text spreads, unexciting chapter openings, generally poor title pages. The typography, on the whole, is extremely weak. The illustrations are also unexciting in the books submitted in this category, and the scanning and printing often poor and, frequently, atrocious. It appears that in many cases the images were found on the internet by the authors, were never intended to be of publication quality, and no one went to the trouble of finding print-quality replacements. So, we chose three books for Honourable Mention.

Prose Non-Fiction Hon. Mention back to general winners

Title

ReCalling Early Canada : Reading the Political in Literary and Cultural Production

Designer

Alan Brownoff

Author

Jennifer Blair, Daniel Coleman, Kate Higginson & Lorraine York (eds)

Publisher

The University of Alberta Press

Photographer

various

Illustrator

Frederick Alexcee (cover)

Printer

Houghton Boston Printers

Trim Size

15 × 23cm

ReCalling Early Canada

Comments

We chose three books for Honourable Mention. The first of these is ReCalling Early Canada. It was refreshing to come across this book, because it is okay. However, the title page is disappointing; the illustrations are predominately historical photographs, and therefore one accepts a low and inconsistent level of quality. The designer has done what could be done with such poor illustrative materials. The text spread is good, and legible; the type itself well-set, and well printed on the page.

Prose Non-Fiction Hon. Mention back to general winners

Title

Jean Béliveau : My Life in Hockey

Designer

Jessica Sullivan & Lisa Hemingway

Author

Jean Béliveau with Chris Goyens & Allan Turowetz

Publisher

Greystone Books

Photographer

various

Printer

Friesens

Trim Size

15 × 22cm

Jean Beliveau: My Life in Hocky

Comments

The cover is a grave disappointment, but the text pages are well set, well designed, the margins ample; all of these things are quite unusual in a sports book. The chapter openings, with hockey pucks carrying the chapter numbers, are quite successful, but the title page is not.

Prose Non-Fiction Hon. Mention back to general winners

Title

The Windshift Line : a Father and Daughter's Story

Designer

Jessica Sullivan

Author

Rita Moir

Publisher

Greystone Books

Photographer

Special photographers / Photonica

Printer

Friesens

Trim Size

13 × 20cm

The Windshift Line

Comments

This, we think, is the best of the three books we chose for Honourable Mention in this category. Pleasant to read, the paper has a decent colour. The introductory material is quietly competent and understated, has a reasonable title page, and the mixture of serif and sans serif types is handled well. The script type employed for visuals at the beginnings of chapters is not so successful.

^ back to top