The Alcuin Society

Alcuin Society Book Design Awards24th Annual Awards for
Excellence in Book Design
in Canada

2005

Français | This Year's Judges

 

Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated

Many of the books submitted in this category thrust both text and images into the reader's face with as much force as possible. We noticed too that this category has attracted books which range from the purely amateurish to the immensely professional, in other words, the entries vary more widely in quality than in any other category of books which we judged in this competition. We elected not to give a first prize.

Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated 2nd Prize
back to general winners

Title

The Bedside Book of Birds : an Avian Miscellany

Designer

CS Richardson

Author

Graeme Gibson

Publisher

Doubleday Canada

Trim Size

15 × 23cm

The Bedside Book of Birds

Comments

This is a lovely book, handsomely designed, handsomely produced. The typographic design, the choice of type, the positioning of images, the relation of text and image, the handling of colour, the choice of paper: all are exemplary. The designer, however, has chosen a typeface that requires the use of ligatures, and the ligatures are absent. It makes an enormous difference. There are some other indications of typographic carelessness. The justification is poor; the paragraphs are often too loose; the quotations are sometimes handled in an inefficient or careless way; and there are defects, such as that on page 180, where the text block has been knocked 3.5 picas (that is, more than half an inch) out of position. In fact, the only thing on page 180 that is where it belongs is the page number. It is also highly unfortunate that this book is not Smyth-sewn. It is a book that will, no doubt, find itself on many bedside tables and will be frequently consulted by interested readers. It ought to be sewn so that it will stay in one piece, and so that it will behave as books must; that is, so that it will open and lie flat, and then open and close again without falling to pieces.

Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated 3rd Prize (tie)
back to general winners

Title

Crows : Encounters with the Wise Guys of the Avian World

Designer

Jessica Sullivan

Author

Candace Savage

Publisher

Greystone Books

Photographer

various

Illustrator

various

Printer

C & C Offset

Trim Size

16 × 22cm

Crows

Comments

This has a very handsome dust jacket. The printed case is not nearly as sophisticated as the jacket. The typography inside the book is generally well done, chapter openings nice but a bit fussy, the spacing of the illustrations good, though many of the images themselves are disappointing. Indeed, what ails this book is that the quality of the images varies so drastically. If you compare the illustrations in this book with those in the inexpensive paperback guide called Hiking the West Coast of Vancouver Island (to which we awarded a prize in the reference category) you see what is missing in Crows; that is, technical attention to the quality of the illustrations.

Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated 3rd Prize (tie)
back to general winners

Title

Safety Gear for Small Animals = Équipement de sécurité pour petits animaux

Designer

Zab Design & Typography

Author

Bill Burns

Publisher

Tom Thomson Memorial Art Gallery & 8 other galleries

Printer

Kromar Printing Ltd

Trim Size

14 × 20cm

Safety Gear for Samll Animals

Comments

This is happily tongue-in-cheek, the type nicely set, the pages excellently designed. The type is printed on paper that suits the type. The pictures are well-integrated with the text, the ligatures are present as they need to be; and it is refreshing to see a bilingual book in which the French and English do not compete with one another, spread after spread, and are not forced to share a single page, nor forced to share a single set of illustrations. The cover is disguised as the cover of a naturalist's pocket book; the paw prints on the endpapers prove that the small animal referred to in the title has survived from the beginning of the book, in English, to the end, in French.

Prose Non-Fiction Illustrated Hon. Mention
back to general winners

Title

The Company of Others : Stories of Belonging

Designer

Susan Turner (Digitopolis Media)

Author

Sandra Shields & David Campion

Publisher

Arsenal Pulp Press

Photographer

David Campion

Printer

Teldon Print Media

Trim Size

17 × 15cm

The Company of Others

Comments

This is a friendly, unpretentious, honest and warm book; simple and dignified, a non-elitist presentation of non-elitist subject matter. The design pays respect to the people who are the subjects of the book. The focus is placed clearly on the illustrations rather than the text, as, no doubt, it ought to be.

^ back to top